HELLBOY Reviews Are Scathing; Reboot Referred To As "One Of The Worst Comic Book Movies Ever Made"

Oh dear. We figured something was up when the Hellboy reboot press screenings took place at such a late stage, and sure enough, it looks like Lionsgate has a big, red, horned turkey on its hands...

By MarkCassidy - Apr 10, 2019 05:04 PM EST

Filed Under: Hellboy

The reviews for Hellboy have begun to pour in, and, to be frank, they're bloody awful.

Although one or two critics did seem to enjoy the movie - to some extent, at least - the majority of write-ups are pretty scathing, with one review even referring to the Neil Marhsall-directed reboot as "one of the worst comic book movies ever made."

While that's likely an exaggeration, you'll be hard pressed to find much in the way of positivity or praise in this first wave of reviews - although most seemed happy enough with David Harbour's take on the demonic hero.

Have a read through some excerpts below, and be sure to keep an eye on Rotten Tomatoes as more reviews come in. Hellboy currently sits at 11% (ouch).

To view all of the review excerpts at once, simply click on the VIEW LIST (ONE PAGE) button below!

i09:

Like two great tastes that somehow don’t go well together, Hellboy’s greatest sin is that it makes you long for the film that it might have been because there’s so much about the movie that works in a vacuum. David Harbour absolutely nails the charming, lunk-ish aspects of Hellboy’s personality, and a handful of the film’s action sequences are legitimately fun to watch before you get back to the slog of the rest of the film.

WGTC:

Hellboy feels editorially chopped to bits, tonally disjointed and created from clashing perspectives that make for the type of "dark, gritty" reboot that misunderstands why certain "dark, gritty" reboots end up working.

BMD:

There are three sequel hooks stapled to the end of this thing, yet somehow it earns none of them. I don't even know how that's possible! Hellboy is some very ill-advised cinema, and those who enjoy the prospect of cinematic trainwrecks are likely to get some joy out of this. Everyone else... well, you all know where to find the better version.

Hitfix:

I spent almost Hellboy‘s entire run time either recoiling in horror or howling with laughter. Like Hellboy‘s climax, the subtext of which is essentially the protagonist heroically screaming “Yuck, girls!” it was perfectly true to the spirit of an extended adolescent metalhead fantasy. I think this is how Hellboy was always meant to be.

Den of Geek:

A soulless, noisy mess of a movie that has far more in common with lesser Underworld or Resident Evil sequels than it does with the work of Guillermo del Toro or Mike Mignola.

The Wrap:

Neil Marshall’s “Hellboy” is a wellspring of creativity, a major superhero movie made for hardcore R-rated horror fans, overflowing with humor and action and scares. It’s ambitious and low-key at the same time, knowing full well that its target audience isn’t the mainstream blockbuster demographic that demands structure or even sanity.

Rendy Reviews:

If you’ve seen one movie from production company Millennium Films, then chances are you’ve seen them all. With features such as The Hitman’s Bodyguard, The Mechanic: Resurrection and London Has Fallen, this testosterone-led studio prides itself in bloody action but stays in the realm of mediocrity because of either a weak script, terrible editing, or cheap visual effects. Hellboy, unfortunately, nails all three!

/Film:

In a word, Hellboy is unpleasant. Other appropriate adjectives to describe this reboot include dreadful, obnoxious, unnecessary, and interminable. Considering the shadow cast by the two Hellboy films written and directed by Guillermo del Toro, it might be easy to presume that this new version simply pales in comparison. Though that’s true, let’s not belabor the point: this Hellboy is quite bad all on its own. There’s no need to compare this to del Toro’s films, because to do so would just inspire pain.

Time Out:

Guillermo del Toro’s original two Hellboy films (from 2004 and 2008) gave us a lovable outsider with a big heart, a bigger fist and a penchant for cats and cigars, but only the fist survives this horrible redo from director Neil Marshall. Where the Mexican filmmaker brought loads of charm, wit and intricate monster designs, his Brit counterpart delivers gore, gristle and a heap of beasties straight from CGI hell. It’s two hours long but feels like an eternity, lurching incoherently from one noisy set-piece to another.

Screen Rant:

The movie has its merits, and the fantasy spectacle may be worth seeing on a big screen, but it's a middle of the road fantasy-action film; it's not bad enough to be so-bad-it's-good and not good enough to be widely appealing. Instead, Hellboy seems bound to be a misfire that quickly gets overshadowed by bigger blockbusters arriving in the coming weeks.

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Acquired By Studio Behind Ben Affleck's Critically Panned HYPNOTIC

Recommended For You:

STAR WARS: THE ACOLYTE First Clip Sees Master Sol Face-Off With "Mae" - Possible SPOILERS

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

285 Comments

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

HeavyMetal4Life - 4/10/2019, 5:12 PM

I only looked at a few reviews but I thought this reaction summed up what a lot of critics are saying: "Hellboy is some very ill-advised cinema, and those who enjoy the prospect of cinematic trainwrecks are likely to get some joy out of this. Everyone else... well, you all know where to find the better version."

dragon316 - 4/10/2019, 5:46 PM

@HeavyMetal4Life - reviews mean shot it’s your own opinion that matters in life people and critics like movie infinity war I did not like infinity war but I look forward to end game what answe to that

HeavyMetal4Life - 4/10/2019, 5:48 PM

@dragon316 - you sound like you're having a rough day

Franshu - 4/10/2019, 6:23 PM

@HeavyMetal4Life - Dragon didn't say anything that wasn't sensible though. It IS true that ins pite of scathing reviws, it's your own opinion that matters. Heck, some films that are curently considered cult films were destroyed by critics back in the day , so it's unwise to blindly follow what reviewers say like sheep.

GreedoSarducci - 4/10/2019, 8:54 PM

@dragon316 - I'm guessing English is a 2nd language for you?

Ace101 - 4/10/2019, 9:28 PM

@dragon316 - bad reviews dont stop me from watching a movie, it just stops me from wasting my money watching it at a cinema instead it gets relagated to my list of movies ill download in a couple months.
Then ill have an opinion on what the movie is like

Drucifer - 4/11/2019, 11:29 AM

@Franshu - Well, beyond the reviews, this movie kind of looks like a disaster just from the trailers. I was already planning on waiting until video for this one, the reviews just tell me I was on the right track to begin with.

Jaspion - 4/10/2019, 5:13 PM

Del Toro:

HeavyMetal4Life - 4/10/2019, 5:13 PM

Bring back Ron Perlman and Guillermo del Toro!!

jarcastanon - 4/10/2019, 6:40 PM

@HeavyMetal4Life - That would be awesome, but not likely. Can't see an academy award winning director being pushed around by a bunch of b-movie producers. He really showed love for the character, but unless he has the creative liberty he had when he was in charge of the franchise, he'll likely decline to return to it.

HeavyMetal4Life - 4/10/2019, 6:42 PM

@jarcastanon - oh I totally agree

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

HELLBOY Reviews Are Scathing; Reboot Referred To As "One Of The Worst Comic Book Movies Ever Made"

Oh dear. We figured something was up when the Hellboy reboot press screenings took place at such a late stage, and sure enough, it looks like Lionsgate has a big, red, horned turkey on its hands...

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Acquired By Studio Behind Ben Affleck's Critically Panned HYPNOTIC

STAR WARS: THE ACOLYTE First Clip Sees Master Sol Face-Off With "Mae" - Possible SPOILERS

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Acquired By Studio Behind Ben Affleck's Critically Panned HYPNOTIC

HELLBOY Star Ron Perlman Addresses Controversial Instagram Post: "We Should Be Loving Each Other"

HELLBOY Star Ron Perlman Issues Warning To Studio Exec: "There's A Lot Of Ways To Lose Your House"

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Acquired By Studio Behind Ben Affleck's Critically Panned HYPNOTIC

HELLBOY Star Ron Perlman Addresses Controversial Instagram Post: "We Should Be Loving Each Other"

HELLBOY Star Ron Perlman Issues Warning To Studio Exec: "There's A Lot Of Ways To Lose Your House"

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Has Finished Shooting; Gets Seal Of Approval From Creator Mike Mignola

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Adds Two More To Its Cast; Brief Official Plot Synopsis Revealed

HELLBOY: THE CROOKED MAN Finds Its Lead In DEADPOOL 2 Actor Jack Kesy

Popular Headlines

RUMOR: SPIDER-MAN 4 Will Feature [SPOILER] But They May Not Have A Significant Role

VISION Is Being Resurrected For A NEW Disney+ Series From STAR TREK: PICARD EP; Paul Bettany Will Return

RUMOR: Taylor Swift's MCU Role May Have Been Revealed (And It Has Ties To Scarlett Johansson)

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Star Hugh Jackman Reveals The Real Reason He Decided To Return As MCU's Logan

X-MEN '97 Director Addresses Decision To Make T'Chaka The Show's Black Panther Instead Of T'Challa

FURIOSA Star Anya Taylor-Joy Reveals Gory Scene That Was Cut From The End Of The Movie - SPOILERS

STAR WARS: THE ACOLYTE First Clip Sees Master Sol Face-Off With "Mae" - Possible SPOILERS

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Eyeing A $100+ Million Opening Weekend Following Record-Breaking First Day Ticket Sales

FURIOSA Star Anya Taylor-Joy Reveals Gory Scene That Was Cut From The End Of The Movie - SPOILERS

STAR WARS: THE ACOLYTE First Clip Sees Master Sol Face-Off With "Mae" - Possible SPOILERS

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Eyeing A $100+ Million Opening Weekend Following Record-Breaking First Day Ticket Sales

X-MEN '97 Director Addresses Decision To Make T'Chaka The Show's Black Panther Instead Of T'Challa

HARRY POTTER Star Gary Oldman Explains Previous Comments About His "Mediocre" Sirius Black Performance

VISION Is Being Resurrected For A NEW Disney+ Series From STAR TREK: PICARD EP; Paul Bettany Will Return

Hot Headlines

SPIDER-MAN 4: Marvel Studios Looking For Director To Helm New Trilogy; BATGIRL Team In Contention?

Marvel Studios’ X-MEN Reboot Has Finally Found A Writer!

RUMOR: YOUNG AVENGERS’ Leads Revealed As Some Venomous SPIDER-MAN 4 Plot SPOILERS Find Their Way Online

TIME BANDITS: Lisa Kudrow Leads The Team In First Look At THOR: LOVE & THUNDER Director Taika Waititi's Reboot

X-MEN Editor Denies Cyclops, Wolverine, And Jean Grey Were A Throuple...But The Evidence Says Otherwise

Sci-Fi & Fantasy

FURIOSA Star Anya Taylor-Joy Reveals The One Scene That Was Cut For Being Too Gruesome - SPOILERS

THE WITCHER Still And Teaser Reveal First Official Look At Liam Hemsworth's Geralt Of Rivia

THE ACOLYTE First Clip Finds Master Sol Doing Battle With His Former Apprentice(?) - Possible SPOILERS

HARRY POTTER Star Gary Oldman Clarifies His Comments About "Mediocre" Sirius Black Performance

ALIEN: ROMULUS Stills Evoke Memories Of ALIENS; Fede Álvarez Explains James Cameron's Involvement

GODZILLA X KONG: THE NEW EMPIRE Director Adam Wingard Will Not Helm Planned Sequel

Cartoons & Animated Features

Beau DeMayo Curiously Absent From Disney+ ASSEMBLED: THE MAKING OF X-MEN '97 Episode

X-MEN '97 Finale May Have Revealed Who Will Return As [SPOILER]'s Four Horsemen In Season 2

X-MEN '97 Director Explains Why T'Challa Wasn't BLACK PANTHER In The Season Finale

X-MEN '97 Is Now The Highest-Rated MCU Project EVER With 100% Rotten Tomatoes Score

KUNG FU PANDA 4 Exclusive Interview With Director Mike Mitchell & Head Of Character Animation Sean Sexton

X-MEN '97 Creative Team Tease Apocalypse Plans, Wolverine's New Status Quo, And Season 2 Production - SPOILERS

Gaming

FORTNITE Chapter 5 Season 3 Teaser Shows Off FALLOUT's T-60 Power Armor And More New Items

First Teasers For CALL OF DUTY: BLACK OPS 6 Revealed: "The Truth Lies"

STREET FIGHTER Reboot Unveils Its First Promo Poster At Licensing Expo

ELDEN RING Reveals New Story Trailer For Highly Anticipated Expansion Next Month

The Entire KINGDOM HEARTS Saga Is Coming To Steam Next Month

MARVEL RIVALS Dataminer Leaks 20 New Characters, Including FANTASTIC FOUR And VENOM

Anime & Manga

GHOST IN THE SHELL 2: INNOCENCE Is Returning To Theaters With 4K Restoration

BLUE ARCHIVE THE ANIMATION Releasing With English Subtitles This Week On YouTube

DEAD DEAD DEMONS DEDEDEDE DESTRUCTION Anime Adaptation Is Coming To Crunchyroll

CALL OF DUTY Announces Crossover Collaboration With MOBILE SUIT GUNDAM

GO! GO! LOSER RANGER! English Dub Premiere Date Announced By Hulu

BERSERK: THE GOLDEN AGE ARC MEMORIAL EDITION Blu-Ray Now Available For Pre-Order

Horror

THE SANDMAN: First Season 2 Teaser Reveals The Rest Of The Endless

BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE Gets A New Poster Ahead Of Thursday's Full Trailer

LONGLEGS: You Might Want To Say Your Prayers Before Watching This Bone-Chilling New Trailer

THE SUBSTANCE Star Demi Moore On Body-Horror Movie's Extreme Violence And Nudity

Cillian Murphy Officially Set To Return For 28 YEARS LATER

THE STRANGERS: CHAPTER 1 Hits Rotten Tomatoes With Worst Score Of The Franchise

Action Movies & TV

Jessica Alba Becomes Vengeance In Kickass Official Trailer For Netflix Actioner TRIGGER WARNING

THE FALL GUY Is Now Available On Digital HD With A Brand New Extended Cut

THE MINISTRY OF UNGENTLEMANLY WARFARE Exclusive Interview With Star Babs Olusanmokun ("Richard Heron")

BAD BOYS: RIDE OR DIE Final Trailer Pits Will Smith & Martin Lawrence Against Crooked Cops & An Alligator?!

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Production Designer Pawas Sawatchaiyamet On Working With Dev Patel

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Mask Designer Eddie Yang; Dev Patel Film Now Available On Digital HD

Pro Wrestling & MMA News

Cody Rhodes Reveals What It Was Like Seeing Fans Turn On The Rock Heading Into WRESTLEMANIA

Rey Mysterio Explains Why WWE Split Him And Son Dominik Up And Whether He's Proud Of His Heel Run

Cody Rhodes Breaks Silence On What The Rock Put In His Hand During RAW After WRESTLEMANIA